This discussion is locked.
You cannot post a reply to this discussion. If you have a question start a new discussion

Question on thermodynamics

Former Community Member
Former Community Member
Hello everyone, I have a question on the energy cost of compressing gas.

I didn't find a community about thermodynamics, so I post the question here..


When gas absorbs heat. its volume increases from v1 to v2. When we compress the volume of the same gas from v2 to v1, does the energy required equal to the heat it absorbs? Does the temperature affect the energy required?


  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member in reply to Chris Pearson

    Tan Wee Ser:

    It depends on what kind of system you are looking at. For engines, water-steam cycle, there can be isothermal process. Try looking at Rankine, Brayton and Otto Cycles.




    Thank you! Do you have any input to the problem in the previous post?

  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member in reply to Chris Pearson

    Tan Wee Ser:

    It depends on what kind of system you are looking at. For engines, water-steam cycle, there can be isothermal process. Try looking at Rankine, Brayton and Otto Cycles.




    Thank you! Do you have any input to the problem in the previous post?

  • It sounds like you are running a sub-critical two phase refrigeration cycle. This is similar to your domestic refrigerator. If you look up refrigeration cycle on Wikepedia it will give you the details and the normal performance measure COP (coefficient of performance), more detail in Cengel and Boles Chapter 10.

    Lynton.
  • It sounds like you are running a sub-critical two phase refrigeration cycle. This is similar to your domestic refrigerator. If you look up refrigeration cycle on Wikepedia it will give you the details and the normal performance measure COP (coefficient of performance), more detail in Cengel and Boles Chapter 10.

    Lynton.
  • It sounds like you are running a sub-critical two phase refrigeration cycle. This is similar to your domestic refrigerator. If you look up refrigeration cycle on Wikepedia it will give you the details and the normal performance measure COP (coefficient of performance), more detail in Cengel and Boles Chapter 10.

    Lynton.
  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member in reply to Chris Pearson

    Lynton Mogridge:

    It sounds like you are running a sub-critical two phase refrigeration cycle. This is similar to your domestic refrigerator. If you look up refrigeration cycle on Wikepedia it will give you the details and the normal performance measure COP (coefficient of performance), more detail in Cengel and Boles Chapter 10.

    Lynton.




    Thanks, I found that the COP in air conditioner is about 3.x,


    If we use 1km copper line, radius is 900 mm2,

    At 20 deg c

    R = 0.0172*10^-6 * 1000 / (900*10^-6) = 0.0191(ohm)

    At 90 deg c, temperature coefficient of resistivity is 0.00393 at 20 deg c

    R = 0.0191*1.00393^70 = 0.02513(ohm)


    The current is 1000A

    P=1000*1000*0.0191=19100(W)

    P90 = 1000*1000*0.02513 = 25130(W)

    Psav = 25130-19100 = 6030(W)


    Per year, the energy saving is

    W = Psav* 24*365 = 52822.8(kw*h)   -- per kilometer


    To keep the line 20 deg c, the input power of compressor should be

    19100/3.5 = 5457.14(W)


    It seems it is worth implementing the solution.

    Am I right? Could anybody working in electricity domain point out the rough difference between the real value and the ideal value?

  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member in reply to Chris Pearson

    Lynton Mogridge:

    It sounds like you are running a sub-critical two phase refrigeration cycle. This is similar to your domestic refrigerator. If you look up refrigeration cycle on Wikepedia it will give you the details and the normal performance measure COP (coefficient of performance), more detail in Cengel and Boles Chapter 10.

    Lynton.




    Thanks, I found that the COP in air conditioner is about 3.x,


    If we use 1km copper line, radius is 900 mm2,

    At 20 deg c

    R = 0.0172*10^-6 * 1000 / (900*10^-6) = 0.0191(ohm)

    At 90 deg c, temperature coefficient of resistivity is 0.00393 at 20 deg c

    R = 0.0191*1.00393^70 = 0.02513(ohm)


    The current is 1000A

    P=1000*1000*0.0191=19100(W)

    P90 = 1000*1000*0.02513 = 25130(W)

    Psav = 25130-19100 = 6030(W)


    Per year, the energy saving is

    W = Psav* 24*365 = 52822.8(kw*h)   -- per kilometer


    To keep the line 20 deg c, the input power of compressor should be

    19100/3.5 = 5457.14(W)


    It seems it is worth implementing the solution.

    Am I right? Could anybody working in electricity domain point out the rough difference between the real value and the ideal value?

  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member in reply to Chris Pearson

    Lynton Mogridge:

    It sounds like you are running a sub-critical two phase refrigeration cycle. This is similar to your domestic refrigerator. If you look up refrigeration cycle on Wikepedia it will give you the details and the normal performance measure COP (coefficient of performance), more detail in Cengel and Boles Chapter 10.

    Lynton.




    Thanks, I found that the COP in air conditioner is about 3.x,


    If we use 1km copper line, radius is 900 mm2,

    At 20 deg c

    R = 0.0172*10^-6 * 1000 / (900*10^-6) = 0.0191(ohm)

    At 90 deg c, temperature coefficient of resistivity is 0.00393 at 20 deg c

    R = 0.0191*1.00393^70 = 0.02513(ohm)


    The current is 1000A

    P=1000*1000*0.0191=19100(W)

    P90 = 1000*1000*0.02513 = 25130(W)

    Psav = 25130-19100 = 6030(W)


    Per year, the energy saving is

    W = Psav* 24*365 = 52822.8(kw*h)   -- per kilometer


    To keep the line 20 deg c, the input power of compressor should be

    19100/3.5 = 5457.14(W)


    It seems it is worth implementing the solution.

    Am I right? Could anybody working in electricity domain point out the rough difference between the real value and the ideal value?

  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member in reply to Chris Pearson

    Weizhi Yao:




    Lynton Mogridge:

    It sounds like you are running a sub-critical two phase refrigeration cycle. This is similar to your domestic refrigerator. If you look up refrigeration cycle on Wikepedia it will give you the details and the normal performance measure COP (coefficient of performance), more detail in Cengel and Boles Chapter 10.

    Lynton.




    Thanks, I found that the COP in air conditioner is about 3.x,


    If we use 1km copper line, radius is 900 mm2,

    At 20 deg c

    R = 0.0172*10^-6 * 1000 / (900*10^-6) = 0.0191(ohm)

    At 90 deg c, temperature coefficient of resistivity is 0.00393 at 20 deg c

    R = 0.0191*1.00393^70 = 0.02513(ohm)


    The current is 1000A

    P=1000*1000*0.0191=19100(W)

    P90 = 1000*1000*0.02513 = 25130(W)

    Psav = 25130-19100 = 6030(W)


    Per year, the energy saving is

    W = Psav* 24*365 = 52822.8(kw*h)   -- per kilometer


    To keep the line 20 deg c, the input power of compressor should be

    19100/3.5 = 5457.14(W)


    It seems it is worth implementing the solution.

    Am I right? Could anybody working in electricity domain point out the rough difference between the real value and the ideal value?


     




    The data model can be simplified to following.

     - The resistance at highest temp / lowest temp are Rh / Rl

     - The cooling COP is cop


    I^2 * (Rh-Rl) > I^2 * Rl / cop

      ==>

    Rh / Rl > (cop+1) / cop


    Substitute sample data of copper at 90 deg C and 20 deg C

    0.0226/0.0172 > (cop+1)/cop  ==>

    cop>3.7


    A little challenging, but if solar energy is used, the required level of cooling COP can be decreased.

    Am I right? Is anybody interested in it?

  • Former Community Member
    0 Former Community Member in reply to Chris Pearson

    Weizhi Yao:




    Lynton Mogridge:

    It sounds like you are running a sub-critical two phase refrigeration cycle. This is similar to your domestic refrigerator. If you look up refrigeration cycle on Wikepedia it will give you the details and the normal performance measure COP (coefficient of performance), more detail in Cengel and Boles Chapter 10.

    Lynton.




    Thanks, I found that the COP in air conditioner is about 3.x,


    If we use 1km copper line, radius is 900 mm2,

    At 20 deg c

    R = 0.0172*10^-6 * 1000 / (900*10^-6) = 0.0191(ohm)

    At 90 deg c, temperature coefficient of resistivity is 0.00393 at 20 deg c

    R = 0.0191*1.00393^70 = 0.02513(ohm)


    The current is 1000A

    P=1000*1000*0.0191=19100(W)

    P90 = 1000*1000*0.02513 = 25130(W)

    Psav = 25130-19100 = 6030(W)


    Per year, the energy saving is

    W = Psav* 24*365 = 52822.8(kw*h)   -- per kilometer


    To keep the line 20 deg c, the input power of compressor should be

    19100/3.5 = 5457.14(W)


    It seems it is worth implementing the solution.

    Am I right? Could anybody working in electricity domain point out the rough difference between the real value and the ideal value?


     




    The data model can be simplified to following.

     - The resistance at highest temp / lowest temp are Rh / Rl

     - The cooling COP is cop


    I^2 * (Rh-Rl) > I^2 * Rl / cop

      ==>

    Rh / Rl > (cop+1) / cop


    Substitute sample data of copper at 90 deg C and 20 deg C

    0.0226/0.0172 > (cop+1)/cop  ==>

    cop>3.7


    A little challenging, but if solar energy is used, the required level of cooling COP can be decreased.

    Am I right? Is anybody interested in it?